Showing posts with label Mind. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mind. Show all posts
5.28.2017
invisible, indivisible
Have been reading a couple books by Borden P. Bowne lately (Metaphysics, and Personalism). Bowne was a professor of philosophy at Boston University a little over 100 years ago. Involved (I believe) with the philosophical circle known as "Boston Personalism". Apparently the group and the school of thought influenced the young Martin Luther King.
Not easy reading for me. I'm not well-versed in philosophy. The mind tends to wander. But Bowne's perspective seems to chime with my own vague hunches about the nature of things. I've always thought of poetry as a counter-force against positivism, materialism, determinism - the supposedly "objective" dehumanization and disenchantment of reality.
In fact Bowne provides a pretty forceful rational and philosophical defense of theism and "personhood". I'm a little surprised his writings are not better known today. He's not merely a Berkeleyan idealist. Nor is he some kind of American pragmatist. Rather he finds a middle way between "common sense" pragmatism (ie. all our knowledge ultimately derives from - and involves a rational abstraction from - ordinary experience) and Kantian idealism (ie. human consciousness orders & thereby interprets any and all experience whatsoever - the mind's insight is what we know).
Experience is not merely a phantasm of consciousness (as in Berkeley). Things are real, things have concrete reality. But mind is not a "thing" : and mind provides the only continuity, freedom, and truth that we know. Bowne posits a sharp (a "metaphysical") divide between invisible mind (or soul, or spirit, or personhood) and the phenomenal world of things. And yet he doesn't presume to define or theorize how "things" came into being. His Occam's razor shreds (satirically) a lot of pretentious theorizing about "being" and "phenomena" etc. He posits a strict difference between the finite and the infinite. And yet he proposes a kinship between limited, finite human mind (consciousness, spirit) and the infinite creative personhood (consciousness, spirit) which must be the creative origin of things. Nothing else will do.
Bowne is not a tendentious apologist for theism : instead, he slowly explores the origins of determinism, positivism, and materialism in our "common sense" response to the apparent "thickness", the substantiality, of things. We are sensualists. We extrapolate from physical, material, bodily experience, and leap to universals and generalizations about how "things must be". We tend to evade the difficult (and very ancient) question about how anything exists at all - how things happen to be (from nothing).
Again, Bowne doesn't presume to answer this question. He just finds a rational way to propose that an infinite creative Mind or Spirit is the only plausible source of what we call reality.
Philosophy can get you thinking, musing. Perhaps we tend to avoid God because she's actually so close to us. There's no "space" between the roots of our own personhood (our "soul", let's say) and the infinite person - except that dividing line (and it's a thick one) between finite and infinite. But the primal analogy is there, the imago Dei. Bowne demonstrates how what we understand by "personality" or personhood is really invisible, immeasurable - our core identity, our rational, emotional, actively volitional personhood, is an invisible intelligence - a soul, a spirit, a heart & mind. & then Bowne demonstrates how the most rational description of the source or "world-ground" of reality as a whole is none other than some infinite (immeasurable, unlimited) form of this invisible intelligence (heart & mind).
Think of the eloquent poetry of Martin Luther King's analogies (between the spirit of divine Agape and the troubled spirits of an earthly people).
This text from the Book of Joel (2:28) seems apropos : "And it shall come to pass afterward that I will pour out my Spirit upon all flesh; and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, your old men shall dream dreams, your young men shall see visions..."
We're close here to the fusion of a very archaic vision of reality (eg. we are all children & beneficiaries of Manitou, the "Great Spirit"), with the most contemporary understanding of the same.
Maybe we're at the beginning of a new cultural sense, or common understanding, of reality - which is not that different from a very old sense.
None of this "proves" (philosophically) the specifically Christian declaration (the "good news" of "Father & Son & Spirit"). The Christian declaration is more radical than philosophical argument per se can propound : ie. Jesus is the personal manifestation of God. This is rather an article of faith. But Bowne is one of those thinkers and writers who provides a general, philosophical framework or ground for an approach to (or rational evaluation of) the obscure "witness" of religious (theological) expression.
(p.s. I know I'm not being completely fair to George Berkeley here. This is Bowne's critique and distinction, not mine. Berkeley, to my mind, seems actually very close to Bowne in his "metaphysics".)
3.25.2017
Dream song of reality
Just read Joshua Rothman's New Yorker profile of philosopher Daniel Dennett, his lifelong pursuit of a materialist, non-religious, un-mystical theory of consciousness. Dennett steps out as a brilliant, original thinker, with an impressive science background (biology, mostly). And as an admirably enterprising DIY jack-of-all-trades.
I'm neither scientist nor philosopher. But I have, like many another, puzzled over the question of "mind", this ancient (back to Epicurus, at least) divide between idealism and materialism.
Just a few off-the-cuff reactions to Rothman's Dennett. He strikes me as a curious, searching person, whose stance toward nature is essentially that of an engineer. He's interested in the mechanics of process - how things are done. This is obviously necessary for science, an attentive approach which leads to discovery. But it seems ironic that Dennett's view of consciousness - as a continuum, shared with other animals and living things - is not that different from the classic "chain of being" perspective of Aquinas (for one example). That other animals exhibit a "sort of" consciousness (Dennett's term) - an evolutionary preview of the human mind - parallels the chain-of-being picture, only without the traditional hierarchical fence between "Man" & the rest. For Dennett it's a flow. & it seems he has focused passionately on explaining (theoretically) the how of it : how our sense of consciousness could arise from purely physical, evolutionary developments.
This is, I would say, the blind spot in Dennett's vision. There are limits to the mechanical, analytical dissection of reality offered by biology. Whatever conclusions he can draw from such analysis only serve to justify his prior conviction of the non-existence of an over-arching God, Spirit, or Mind - something which cannot be "proved" by such analysis anyway.
It seems to me that aesthetics & poetry, as well perhaps as some branches of philosophy, can offer a more valid perspective - because they are rooted in a sense of holism, a synthetic sense.
The poet and the artist register the fabric of the dream. The theologian (or philosopher of God) articulates the analogical/anagogical synthesis. Materialist attempts to disprove the reality of Mind or Spirit lack the tools to achieve it, first of all - and, secondly, are probably asking the wrong question.
The question, maybe, is not how, but why. Why does this immense spectacle of the universe exist at all? "We are such things as dreams are made on..." - but why?
I've always found the theological answer the most satisfactory. Why the wonder of the cosmos? The truest answer : it's a gift. Why human consciousness? The truest answer is a kind of geometric/analogical one : human consciousness, which governs (imperfectly) life on our planet, demonstrates an analogy - a sort of geometric parallel - with the divine Mind that governs (ineffably) Reality as a whole. And history is basically a spectacular drama, unfolding the destiny of that governing mind or spirit, working through humanity toward some kind (or kinds) of definitive expression - call it "Providence".
Labels:
aesthetics,
analysis,
atheism,
Daniel Dennett,
dream,
idealism,
Joshua Rothman,
materialism,
Mind,
naturalism,
nature,
New Yorker,
Providence,
reality,
science,
synthesis,
theism,
theology,
universe
9.30.2016
the love that draws the sun & the other galaxies
IRIS-TURTLE
The curve of the river twines the curve
of the path, they skip together
downstream. Warm autumn weather
clears the mind a little (light mauve
asters nodding under cottonwoods).
The poem’s woven trace
catches the vif, the grace
of movement – Berkeley’s moods
in Paradise (Newport)... his eyes
commingling a million
threads beneath the sun
into a massive sky-warp of surprise –
Daphne’s comb or seaweed wave
of tears (the patient laurel
lifts gnarled arms from Hell
into the marrow of yawning grave).
The living mind, the raven-shadow
of Platonic iris-turtle... Venn
diagram or madrigal (ken
you my mosey-keening yet?) – below
the longing of the galaxies,
their milky sarabande –
a spectrum of star-sand,
poured from hand to hand. He’s
just daydreaming of Marina now
(sea-daughter, blithe naiad
of Taurida) – be glad
you’ve followed his light-dancing prow.
9.30.16
Labels:
Aristotle,
Berkeley,
love,
Mandelstam,
Marina,
Mind,
Paradise (neighborhood),
Plato,
rivers,
Tsvetaeva,
Venn diagram
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

